Skip to Main Content

PETA Asks Law Enforcement to Investigate ‘Hobbit’ Death Trap

Written by Michelle Kretzer | November 26, 2012

Following PETA’s release last week of disturbing whistleblower reports of 27 animal deaths during the filming of The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, we have asked authorities in New Zealand, where The Hobbit was filmed, to investigate and pursue appropriate criminal charges if warranted.

The five whistleblowers, all wranglers who worked on the film set, allege the following:

  • Two geldings ran a pony named Rainbow off an embankment in the paddock that they were all housed in. The next morning, Rainbow was found still alive and suffering, with his neck and back broken, and had to be euthanized.
  • A horse named Doofus was housed with two geldings even though they had already injured the pony. He was subsequently found tangled in the fence, the skin and muscles torn from his leg, surrounded by hoofprints that indicated a fight.
  • A horse named Clare was run over a bank by other horses in her paddock, most likely because there was not sufficient space or grass for them all. She was found with her neck broken and her head submerged in the river.
  • A horse named Zeppelin died suddenly after displaying symptoms of colic, which can result from feeding grain to a horse who isn’t accustomed to it. Zeppelin’s typical diet was grass and hay, but he was fed grain on the set.
  • A horse named Shanghai was hobbled (his legs were tied together so that he couldn’t move) and left lying on the ground for more than three hours. The resulting rope burns were covered up for filming. Hobbling is a violation of the guidelines of the American Humane Association (AHA), the agency that monitors the treatment of animals on film and television productions.
  • A horse named Molly became tangled in wire fencing in her paddock, tearing the skin and muscle from her leg.
  • Numerous goats and sheep died from worm infestations and from falling into sinkholes. 
  • Twelve chickens were killed by dogs who weren’t properly supervised.

Reportedly, the AHA monitors who were supposed to be ensuring the animals’ safety were overly friendly with the head trainer—who was himself distracted by other projects—and the AHA was absent for many of the animal sequences. Allegedly, three horses died before the AHA investigated and recommended improvements in housing. The wranglers also report that they voiced their concerns to the unit production manager but were ignored.

In September, PETA contacted the AHA about reported problems on The Hobbit set, but we’ve yet to receive a response. PETA wrote to director Peter Jackson to find out what, if anything, he knew about the animals’ deaths during production. The man who brought us the superb computer-generated imagery (CGI) that won him our Proggy (for “progress”) Award for King Kong has the ability to make the animals and other interesting creatures in his movies 100 percent CGI, and PETA calls on him to do so again.

In the age of Oscar-winning digital effects, there is no reason why a single animal should suffer for a film. Join PETA in urging Jackson to continue to use cutting-edge CGI and give his assurance that no animal will ever suffer again for one of his movies.

Commenting is closed.
  • Dean says:

    My wife and I really wanted to see The Hobbit But being very ordinary people we will choose to STAY HOME and enjoy our 9 cats.By the way it will not end here.We have long memorys. Feel free to pass this on.I have no problem being an animal lover.

  • Laurie says:

    I will not be watching the hobbit.And i have spread the word and will continue too.Senseless killings for a movie!!

  • Peg Herlihy says:

    It’s deplorable to cause pain to another creature and should reault in punishable consequences. I will not watch any more Hobbit movies. How about a percentage of the profit from the movie to be given for the care and rehabilitation of abused animals as a start?

  • Kristina Bogdani says:

    Greetings from Croatia. Like David, I also support his decision not to watch the movie. Where there’s smoke there’s fire.. So I’m definitely not going to watch the movie.

  • David Wang says:

    Okay. I take this seriously. I love The Hobbit. It’s one of my favorite stories and I loved the Lord of the Rings Trilogy. That said, I will NOT watch a film where I know that anyone or any animal I see in it suffered in a preventable fashion. I need facts. Peter Jacskon denies any animals suffered in the making of the film, so does Elijah Woods. These are serious allegations. I need to know if they are true. If they are, I will NOT watch the film or the following two films, and I will tell everyone I know why I am not watching the film. To Peta : please continue to push for an impartial and unbiased investigation done of the animal abuse allegations. We need hard facts to make this decision. To Peter Jackson : if this proves to be untrue, I can’t wait to see the film! That said, if animals did suffer and die on your set, I will need an apology and a monetary recompense to the animals owners so they can improve the conditions of their farms. Let us leave no question to the fact that it is people’s wallets which rule the day in our world. Mine is for fair treatment of animals in the films I watch.

  • Sharon says:

    I would like to know the truth! I will not see the movie until I have that, and I’ve shared the story.

  • Georgina Hope says:

    Totally appalled – will not go see this movie now

  • jeannine wietrich says:

    Laissait les animaux tranquilles. STOP A LA SOUFFRANCE ANIMAL,Ils ont le droit de vivrent heureux

  • VIRUSEATER says:


  • Pepine says:

    Please,investigate and pursue appropriate criminal charges if warranted. Thanks! Pepine

  • Fabio says:

    Please Investigate ‘Hobbit’ Death Trap !

  • Kat Clem says:

    sick. refusing to see that film now.